Issue description:
Hi! I’m just creating issues as I’m finding them, I hope that’s fine.
When I add multiple rules with “Any” selector, adding a rule should never reduce the number of items in a playlist, yet that’s exactly what I saw.
I created a playlist with such rules:
- song is favorite
- artist is favorite
- album is favorite
- user rating > 3
- rating > 4
And noticed that some of my favorited songs weren’t showing up. Narrowed it down a little, as the logs/screenshots will show:
Logs:
Upload description: prone-to-drift favorites-issue
Additional information:
Outputs of beet info for the two files in question:
/music/blackbox/Korean/Compilations/시그널 (tvN 드라마) OST/04 길.flac
acoustid_fingerprint: {removed to avoid spam}
acoustid_id: ad412716-993b-4de5-9755-40f8caff5c0f
album: 시그널 (tvN 드라마) OST
albumartist: Various Artists
albumartist_credit: Various Artists
albumartist_sort: Various Artists
albumdisambig:
albumstatus: Official
albumtype: a
albumtypes: a; l; b; u; m; ;; ; c; o; m; p; i; l; a; t; i; o; n
arranger:
art: True
artist: 김윤아
artist_credit: 김윤아
artist_sort: Kim, Yuna
asin:
bitdepth: 16
bitrate: 828286
bitrate_mode:
bpm: 0
catalognums:
channels: 2
comments: 30183126
comp: True
composer:
composer_sort:
country:
disc: 1
disctitle:
disctotal: 2
encoder:
encoder_info:
encoder_settings:
format: FLAC
genre: 댄스/팝,OST
genres: 댄스/팝,OST
grouping:
isrc:
label: Stone Music Entertainment
language: kor
languages: kor
length: 265.79437641723354
lyricist:
lyrics: {removed}
mb_albumartistid: 89ad4ac3-39f7-470e-963a-56509c546377
mb_albumartistids: 89ad4ac3-39f7-470e-963a-56509c546377
mb_albumid: 6668dbe2-1818-4dde-bb7e-2856f162f478
mb_artistid: ec8a7e36-2432-4946-8227-876749a1a2da
mb_artistids: ec8a7e36-2432-4946-8227-876749a1a2da
mb_releasegroupid: 025aa2c4-2646-4dcd-aac1-ca9b047e99b9
mb_releasetrackid: f7876450-eba2-4528-9ba0-92db53cbab64
mb_trackid: 2532b816-976c-49dc-9bc3-58a899e93e04
mb_workid:
media: CD
original_year: 0
rg_album_gain: -6.93
rg_album_peak: 1.370268
rg_track_gain: -9.48
rg_track_peak: 1.05632
samplerate: 44100
script: Kore
title: 길
track: 4
tracktotal: 40
year: 0
/music/blackbox/Korean/Compilations/시그널 (tvN 드라마) OST/01 나는 너를.flac
acoustid_fingerprint: {removed}
acoustid_id: 15023b19-15bd-47a2-8d4b-d1ca0aafb1ee
album: 시그널 (tvN 드라마) OST
albumartist: Various Artists
albumartist_credit: Various Artists
albumartist_sort: Various Artists
albumdisambig:
albumstatus: Official
albumtype: a
albumtypes: a; l; b; u; m; ;; ; c; o; m; p; i; l; a; t; i; o; n
arranger:
art: True
artist: 정차식
artist_credit: 정차식
artist_sort: Jeong, Cha-sik
asin:
bitdepth: 16
bitrate: 1006020
bitrate_mode:
bpm: 0
catalognums:
channels: 2
comments: 30183123
comp: True
composer:
composer_sort:
country:
disc: 1
disctitle:
disctotal: 2
encoder:
encoder_info:
encoder_settings:
format: FLAC
genre: 댄스/팝,OST
genres: 댄스/팝,OST
grouping:
isrc:
label: Stone Music Entertainment
language: kor
languages: kor
length: 263.5506575963719
lyricist:
lyrics: {removed}
mb_albumartistid: 89ad4ac3-39f7-470e-963a-56509c546377
mb_albumartistids: 89ad4ac3-39f7-470e-963a-56509c546377
mb_albumid: 6668dbe2-1818-4dde-bb7e-2856f162f478
mb_artistid: 902d372b-51ac-4b48-81b0-188316d26a91
mb_artistids: 902d372b-51ac-4b48-81b0-188316d26a91
mb_releasegroupid: 025aa2c4-2646-4dcd-aac1-ca9b047e99b9
mb_releasetrackid: 910f0100-0823-4bff-a7a5-a1e52d913b07
mb_trackid: 48bce90d-0496-4677-a4ef-99acf4c36187
mb_workid:
media: CD
original_year: 0
rg_album_gain: -6.93
rg_album_peak: 1.370268
rg_track_gain: -9.96
rg_track_peak: 1.11322
samplerate: 44100
script: Kore
title: 나는 너를
track: 1
tracktotal: 40
year: 0
Reproduction steps:
1. Create smart playlist with single rule: song is favorite. Observe the item count. (9 in my screenshot)
2. Edit playlist to add rule: artist is favorite. Observe the item count reduce. (7 in my screenshot)
Media provider:
Subsonic
Screenshots:
So it can return things without ids or things that are not returned from a call to another endpoint because (well I’m still trying to understand the why).