Settings & Expected Behavior for "Split Albums by"

Issue description:

This isn’t necessarily an issue but an observation as I’m not sure this setting is working as expected.

I recently downloaded an album in a Radio / Clean Version as well as an explicit Version.
I Tagged the explicit version & then copied the tags over to the Clean version of the album, The only changes made were to the Explicit Tags & the album covers (the clean version does not have the infamous “Parental Advisory” badge

On my device I placed the two albums in different directories. In my provider settings I had Checked the following under Split Albums by:
Album Artist
Year

This unfortunately led to two albums instead of one combined album even though the Album artist & year tags are identical for both the clean & explicit versions of this album

Logs:

Upload description: No Logs

Additional information:

 
For some context. I’m using the Global Filter or “Top Filter” button which simply allows the user to include / exclude various providers as well as Directories which is INCREDIBLY handy.

Often times I want to play songs in my library but the crowd I’m with requires a radio friendly version. In those scenarios I can enable one of my alternate directories & bam, I have the clean versions of songs at my disposal. After my outing I can go right back to my usual albums Immediately. All the alternates disappear until they are needed again.
 

Reproduction steps:

 
After unchecking all the options under
“Split Albums by”
In symfonium both versions appear in one unified album & not two. My issue was solved but I had assumed even with the options I had selected before that a combined album would be the result.

Is a duplicate album expected behavior with Album Artist & Year selected in “Split Albums By”?

I can upload files if need be but again they are Twins with only changes to the Explicit Tags & embedded album Art. All Else is Exactly the same.
 

Media provider:

Local device

Screenshots:

     

You already know that I need the logs and the files, the wizard also confirms it …

There was a chance I misunderstood the setting usage & was in for a quick explanation Lol.

Description:
“Split By Albums - Issue?”

Uploaded:
Logs
Files
Screen Recording

So you are splitting the album over multiple different libraries not just folder.

This is mostly expected due to the way artists are handled to be filterable per library.

Not much I can do here without breaking other things.

So each directory I’ve added from my local device is considered its own library?

If so that’s interesting as I had not thought of them that way. The good news is I don’t believe action needs to he taken. After unchecking all the options under Split Albums By I was able to achieve my desired outcome I was just unsure how it should work so I wanted to ask.

Now we know & this can be referenced by others :ok_hand:t5:

Side note. I also noticed the tracks appear in smart playlists as they should, but when the top filter is used to filter out those tracks they still remain in the smart playlists instead of dissappearing.

So in the case of the files i sent they both show up on the same smart playlist but the top filter has no effect on weather those tracks remain present in the playlist or not